Equipment Financing and Leasing
FMV Lease vs. $1 Buyout: Payments, Ownership, and Tax Differences
Equipment Financing and Leasing

The core difference between these two equipment lease structures comes down to when ownership is decided. A $1 buyout lease locks in ownership at signing, for a nominal price (for example $1, hence the name) at the end of the term. An FMV (Fair Market Value) lease leaves that decision open until the lease term ends upon which you can decide to return it, renew it, or purchase it for its market value at that time. These two lease structures create differences in monthly payment size, what happens at lease-end, and how the lease is treated for accounting purposes. Each may be more suitable depending on the equipment type and your company’s goals.
What Is a $1 Buyout Lease?
A $1 buyout lease is an equipment lease in which the business purchases the equipment for a nominal price, commonly $1, once the lease term ends. Because ownership is essentially guaranteed from the start, it functions more like a loan than a traditional lease: the business is paying off the full cost of the equipment over time, and the $1 payment at the end is a formality.
A $1 buyout lease is commonly associated with finance lease treatment (formerly capital lease treatment) because it is structured around eventual ownership. Specific accounting treatment depends on the terms of the agreement and applicable accounting standards."
Pros and Cons of a $1 Buyout Lease
Pros:
- Guaranteed ownership of the equipment once the term ends
- A straightforward structure that's easy to understand and budget against, since the outcome is set at signing
- Potential depreciation benefits, since the business owns the asset and may be able to claim deductions like depreciation or Section 179 (a tax advisor can confirm what applies to your situation)
Cons:
- Higher monthly payments than an FMV lease, since the business is financing the full cost of the equipment
- Responsibility for eventually reselling or disposing of the equipment, since there's no return option built into the lease
- Less flexibility if equipment needs change, since the business is committed to ownership from the start
What Is a Fair Market Value (FMV) Lease?
A Fair Market Value (FMV) lease is where the buyout price isn't fixed at signing. Instead, it's set later, based on what the equipment is worth once the lease term ends. When the term is up, the business typically has three options: purchase the equipment at its fair market value at that time, return it to the lessor, or renew the lease.
Pros and Cons of an FMV Lease
Pros:
- Lower monthly payments than a $1 buyout lease, since the business isn't financing the equipment's full value
- Flexibility to upgrade to newer equipment or return it at lease-end instead of being locked into ownership
- No long-term ownership commitment, which suits equipment that may not be needed, or may be outdated, once the term ends
Cons:
- No ownership of the equipment unless the buyout option is exercised at lease-end
- The buyout price isn't known until the term ends, which can make long-range planning less precise
- May involve stricter qualification or appraisal requirements than a straightforward buyout structure
FMV Lease vs. $1 Buyout Lease: Key Differences
Both structures get a business the equipment it needs, but they differ across four practical dimensions: how much you pay monthly, what happens when the term ends, how the lease is treated for accounting and tax purposes, and which types of equipment each one tends to fit best.
Monthly Payment Amount
Monthly payments are the most immediate difference a business will notice, and they come down to how much of the equipment's value each structure finances.
- $1 Buyout Leasing: Payments are higher because the business is financing the full purchase price of the equipment over the lease term, plus financing charges.
- FMV Leasing: Payments are generally lower because the lease is structured with an estimated residual value for the equipment at the end of the term, rather than around recovering its full cost through the scheduled lease payments.
If keeping monthly costs down matters more to your company than guaranteed ownership, that alone can point toward an FMV lease as the better fit.
End of Lease Flexibility and Ownership
The two structures also diverge in what happens once the term is up, and how much say the business has in that outcome.
- $1 Buyout Leasing: Ownership transfers automatically at term-end for a nominal fee. Ownership is guaranteed, but there's also no way to walk away if the equipment is no longer needed.
- FMV Leasing: The business chooses between purchasing at fair market value, renewing the lease, or returning the equipment. That choice is made at term-end, once the equipment's actual condition and value are known.
A business that already knows it wants to keep the equipment long-term may see less value in that flexibility; a business unsure of its future needs will likely see more.
Accounting and Tax Treatment
FMV and $1 buyout leases may receive different accounting and tax treatment depending on the structure and specific terms of the agreement.
- $1 Buyout Leasing: Because the structure is designed around eventual ownership, a $1 buyout lease is commonly associated with finance lease treatment (formerly referred to as a capital lease).
- FMV Leasing: An FMV lease provides flexibility at lease-end, but its accounting classification depends on the specific terms of the agreement and applicable accounting standards.
Because treatment varies by business, lease terms, and applicable accounting standards, a tax advisor should be consulted before assuming how either structure will affect a specific business's taxes.
Use Cases and Application
The type of equipment being financed is often the clearest signal for which structure fits better.
- $1 Buyout Leasing: Tends to fit durable, long-life equipment, like heavy machinery or vehicles, that a business plans to keep and use for many years.
- FMV Leasing: Tends to fit fast-obsolescing or technology-driven equipment, like IT hardware or medical devices, where the ability to upgrade or return equipment matters more than eventual ownership.
Matching the lease structure to how long the equipment is expected to stay useful is one of the more reliable ways to decide between one structure over the other.
Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Leasing Structure
Before committing to either structure, consider these practical questions about how the equipment will be used:
- How long do we realistically expect to use this equipment?
- Is this equipment likely to become outdated or obsolete before we're done using it?
- Do we want to own this equipment outright, or would returning or upgrading it be more useful?
- How important is keeping monthly payments as low as possible right now?
- Are we prepared to handle resale or disposal of the equipment ourselves?
- How does each structure affect our accounting and tax position, and have we checked with our tax advisor?
If the equipment is durable and you're confident you'll want to keep it, a $1 buyout lease likely makes sense. If the equipment is likely to change or become outdated, an FMV lease likely offers more useful flexibility.
Working through these questions is easier with a financing partner who can structure terms around your answers, rather than a fixed product. Broadleaf's equipment financing solutions are built around that kind of end-of-lease flexibility, so businesses aren't forced to commit to a structure before the details are clear.
Find an Equipment Leasing Solution That Fits Your Project's Needs
In short: an FMV lease tends to fit businesses that want flexibility and fast-changing equipment needs, including financing IT and technology equipment, while a $1 buyout lease tends to fit long-term, stable-value assets a business already plans to own. Broadleaf works with businesses to structure FMV leases, $1 buyout leases, and other financing tools around the specifics of the equipment and the project, rather than defaulting to one fixed product. If you're weighing which structure fits your next equipment purchase, get in touch to talk through the details.
Let's Discuss Your Financing Strategy
Tell us about the equipment and timeline you're working with, and we'll help you find the right structure.
Talk to Our Team









